What is a Standardised Mortality Ratio? What are the limitations of using this ratio to compare the performance of Intensive Care Units?
Standardised Mortality Ratio is defined as the observed mortality rate/expected mortality rate. Need to estimate expected mortality rate using a scoring system (eg. APACHE II or III, SAPS II or MPM). Better than comparison of non-adjusted mortality data.
The potential limitations of the system are multiple including: inconsistencies and inaccuracies associated with collection of data and scoring (eg. GCS, recording of parameters); problems of missing data limiting inclusion of all patients; problems of patient mix not adequately accounted for by the original population used for calculation of formulae (eg. transferred patients or delays before admission); small numbers of patients (increasing the error of the SMR estimate); accuracy of the prediction model; relying on mortality as a surrogate marker for quality of care; cost of use of proprietary system; etc.
This question closely resembles Question 30 from the second paper of 2006.
Definition of the SMR
Limitations of the SMR
Limitations of comparing ICUs with the SMR:
Liddell, F. D. "Simple exact analysis of the standardised mortality ratio."Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health 38.1 (1984): 85-88.
Wolfe, Robert A. "The standardized mortality ratio revisited: improvements, innovations, and limitations." American Journal of Kidney Diseases 24.2 (1994): 290-297.
Gaffey, William R. "A critique of the standardized mortality ratio." Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine 18.3 (1976): 157-160.
Jones, Michael E., and Anthony J. Swerdlow. "Bias in the standardized mortality ratio when using general population rates to estimate expected number of deaths." American journal of epidemiology 148.10 (1998): 1012-1017.
van Gestel, Yvette RBM, et al. "The hospital standardized mortality ratio fallacy: a narrative review." Medical care 50.8 (2012): 662-667.
Combes, Alain, et al. "Adverse effect on a referral intensive care unit's performance of accepting patients transferred from another intensive care unit*."Critical care medicine 33.4 (2005): 705-710.