Question 17

a) Outline the pathophysiological effects of sepsis on host immunity, coagulation and endothelial function. (3 marks)
b) Discuss the challenges of diagnosing and managing sepsis in the elderly. (7 marks)

[Click here to toggle visibility of the answers]

College answer

Syllabus topic/section:

2.1.3 Sepsis and Infections: / Sepsis and septic shock: L1
2.1.16 Populations requiring special considerations in Intensive Care / Frail and Aged: L1

Discussion:  

The question was targeted towards the effects of sepsis, explicitly regarding host immunity, coagulation and endothelial function. Despite this, some candidates did not comment on the specifics of these headings. Candidates who were able to explain the pathophysiology and give a clinical example did well.
E.g. Endothelial function is disrupted by circulating cytokines and other mediators (NO) leading to increased vascular permeability and coagulation disorders, clinically evidenced by oedema, poor tissue perfusion, microvascular thrombosis, bleeding and vasoplegia.
Candidates are reminded to read the question carefully: many missed the word “elderly” in part B and gave a generic answer not specific to this population. Heading used could include, but not limited by, short discussions on atypical presentations, role of co-morbidities, immunosuppression, cognitive impairment, polypharmacy effect, social issues and physiological changes affecting treatment responses. There are other headings which would also demonstrate competency in this section of the syllabus.
The marking rubric is included to aid the candidate's future study.

Domain

Below standard

Standard

Above standard

a) Pathophysiology of sepsis

(3 marks)

Superficial discussion of <= 3 areas of pathophysiology

0-1.0 mark

discuss all three areas of pathophysiology in limited detail.

1.5 marks

Plus, addition of Key points of all 3 areas of pathophysiology including activation of cytokines

2.0-3.0 marks

b) Challenges of diagnosis and management in the elderly

(7 marks)

Superficial description or narrow focus missing either atypical presentation,

or comorbidities, or polypharmacy or

age related physiological changes

0-3.0 marks

Reference to frailty, physiology and end-of- life decisions with examples

3.5-4.5 marks

Plus, addition of:

Detailed description

Most key areas discussed in detail with most of aforementioned topics covered

5.0-7.0 marks

Discussion

The first part of this question could not have possibly expected very much from the candidates, as for three marks, a question with three aspects could only be afforded a minute per aspect, leaving the candidate with roughly 25 handwritten words, maximum. How do you explain the effect of sepsis on host immunity in 25 words? 

Perhaps like this?

  • Initial proinflammatory state (endothelial activation, oedema, fever) - improve immune response at the cost of organ function
  • Later, counteregulatory immunosuppression and increased susceptibility to secondary infection

That's 23 words. 25 if you consider "counteregulatory" and  "immunosuppression" as two words, because technically they are, and also they are long and difficult to spell.

Now, let's do coagulation:

  • Endothelial permeability and complement activation lead to activation of pro and anti-thrombotic pathway - leading to platelet activation, DIC, microvascular thromboemboli and organ dysfunction

Again, 23 words, except for the use of the mellifluously polysyllabic words "microvascular thromboemboli" which most normal people would count double. 

As for endothelial function:

  • Inflammatory mediators disrupt the glycocalyx,  increase vascular permeability, produce oedema, decrease catecholamine sensitivity and cause vasoplegia with microvascular shunting, which impairs organ perfusion.

23 words. The trainees in the exam do not have the luxury of painstakingly rewording their responses until they trim every possible shred of superfluous verbiage, so the end result for most people would have been something longer.

The second part of the question is far more important and seems like a fair question to ask in the era of a rapidly expanding population of elders. The question sounds like it is asking to be subdivided into diagnosis and management challenges, but on closer inspection, one notices that this would actually make the answer harder. The only way out is to subdivide further and further:

  • Challenges of assessment of sepsis in the elderly
    • History
      • Communication barriers, altered level of baseline cognition or delirium
      • Atypical presentation: often the presenting symptoms are nonspecific (delirium, lethargy, incontinence, falls, dyspnoea)
      • Delayed presentation due to social isolation, or late detection by lay carers in an institution
    • Examination
      • Fever may be absent 
      • Anatomical site of sepsis may be harder to assess due to poor cooperation or distracting sources of  acute or chronic pain
      • Fluid balance is harder to assess (baseline poor skin turgor, chronic oedema, etc)
    • Investigations
      • Leukocytosis may be absent; procalcitonin may not be elevated; CRP may be chronically elevated 
    • Diagnostic reasoning
      • ​​​​​​​The presence of multiple comorbidities presents a distraction, as there may multiple alternative diagnostic possibilities other than sepsis
      • Polypharmacy interferes with vital signs (each masking tachycardia) and creates confounding organ dysfunction findings
  • Challenges of management of sepsis in the elderly
    • ​​​​​​​Resuscitation
      • ​​​​​​​Diastolic dysfunction is prevalent: response to fluid boluses may be unpredictable
      • Vasopressor tolerance may be limited by AF and peripheral perfusion
      • There is doubt as to the correct MAP target
      • Trial data to describe the over-80s is lacking
    • Specific management
      • ​​​​​​​Source control may be impossible as the patient's goals of care may not be served by aggressive interventions
      • Anbtibiotic therapy needs to be broader (greater risk of MRO and gram negative organism) and adjusted to impaired clearance
    • Supportive management
      • ​​​​​​​Increased risk of malnutrition
      • Higher requirements for post-ICU rehabilitiation
      • Greater risk of pressure injuries
      • Slower recovery
      • Longer hospital stay, and therefore higher risk of complications such as DVT, PE, MI, hospital-acq
    • End of life decisionmaking
      • ​​​​​​​High mortality and morbidity in this age group (age is independently associated with mortality)
      • Increased risk of organ dysfunction means higher level of more intrusive support may be required
      • Often irreversible pathology (eg malignancy) coexists with apparently reversible infection
      • Treating infection may offer symptom control at the end of life

References

Clifford, Kalin M., et al. "Challenges with diagnosing and managing sepsis in older adults." Expert review of anti-infective therapy 14.2 (2016): 231-241.

Ibarz, Mercedes, et al. "The critically ill older patient with sepsis: a narrative review." Annals of Intensive Care 14.1 (2024): 6.

Martin, Greg S., David M. Mannino, and Marc Moss. "The effect of age on the development and outcome of adult sepsis." Critical care medicine 34.1 (2006): 15-21.