Critically evaluate the use of veno-venous extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (V-V ECMO) for hypoxaemic respiratory failure in adults.
Your answer should include:
a) The criteria used to determine if a patient is a suitable candidate for V-V ECMO. (4 marks)
b) Advantages and disadvantages of V-V ECMO in this context. (3 marks)
c) The evidence for V-V ECMO in hypoxaemic respiratory failure. (3 marks)
Syllabus topic/section:
2.1.4 Cardiovascular Intensive Care: Mechanical supports ECMO: L1
Discussion:
Some candidates had a limited knowledge of VV ECMO and its physiological benefits and at times confused it with VA ECMO, particularly in part b).
Many candidates only provided the indications for VV ECMO in part a) and didn’t include the contraindications that would also determine a candidate's suitability for VV ECMO.
In part b) some candidates included broad statements like “prevents death or worsening organ failure” rather than describing the specific advantages of reduced ventilatory pressure to prevent further lung injury or reduction in hypoxia by returning fully oxygenated blood and clearing CO2.
The last part of the question was generally poorly answered, with few candidates demonstrating knowledge of the evidence or the controversies and little appreciation of the differing interpretations of the trials.
Yes, ECMO might be described as a niche therapy available only in the Sandstone Centres of University-Affiliated Excellence, but the college does insist on producing high-quality fellows capable of working everywhere, and nobody would view them as a complete package if they cannot at least demonstrate some passing knowledge of this technology. The last time this came up, as Question 23 from the second paper of 2014 and Question 11 from the second paper of 2010, the pass rates were 43% and 19%, respectively.
a) Criteria for suitability
a) Advantages and disadvantages
The trainees answering this question would potentially be confused by the wording. "Advantages and disadvantages" of something usually means it is being compared to another option. What would that be in this case? Prone ventilation? Hypoxia and death? Hard to know. In this scenario, the safest stance to take would be "VV ECMO vs maximum conventional support including prone ventilation and/or inhaled pulmonary vasodilators", because that is the sort of position one would be forced into when ECMO is needed but not available.
Advantages
Disadvantages
c) The evidence for V-V ECMO in hypoxaemic respiratory failure:
There are only really two trials one can mention here:
Akoumianaki, Evangelia, et al. "A rational approach on the use of extracorporeal membrane oxygenation in severe hypoxemia: advanced technology is not a panacea." Annals of Intensive Care 11.1 (2021): 107.
Rao, Prashant, et al. "Venoarterial extracorporeal membrane oxygenation for cardiogenic shock and cardiac arrest: cardinal considerations for initiation and management." Circulation: Heart Failure 11.9 (2018): e004905.
Peek, Giles J., et al. "Efficacy and economic assessment of conventional ventilatory support versus extracorporeal membrane oxygenation for severe adult respiratory failure (CESAR): a multicentre randomised controlled trial." Lancet (London, England) 374.9698 (2009): 1351-1363.
Combes et al, "Extracorporeal Membrane Oxygenation for Severe Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome". NEJM, N Engl J Med 2018; 378:1965-1975