Basic foundations of acid-base chemistry for the intensivist

This chapter is barely relevant to Section J of the 2023 CICM Primary Syllabus, which describes the expectations of the Court of Examiners for what is the minimum expected standard in ICU training for the understanding of acid-base chemistry as it relates to the working of the human body. This seems like a critically important topic and one is surprised that more attention is not devoted to it in this basic sciences exam.  The acidity of your precious bodily fluids is a carefully guarded parameter, and to allow this parameter to deviate out of a very narrow range would massively impair your capacity to continue living. Basic molecular services would break down. Cellular anarchy would ensue. In order for the ICU physician to wrest a form of order from this chaos, a reasonable grasp of basic acid-base chemistry should be expected. Perhaps that is the spirit of the syllabus item J1(ii), "explain the principles underlying acid-base chemistry".

There are plenty of official resources out there for this, and the trainee is first redirected to these, as the weight of their peer-reviewed muscle will be greater than that of this website. But if a free online resource is preferred by the reader, then one could not do better than the excellent medically themed foundation for acid-base chemistry laid by Kerry Brandis in a highly acclaimed series of online articles. To supercede this resource is not the intention, as it remains canonical for all critical care trainees; and in fact the earliest primitive forms of Deranged Physiology began in 2009, as an attempt to write footnotes for Brandis. 

Unfortunately, when one performs a parega and paralipmena like this, one inevitably ends up writing ten times more than the original source. To spare the reader from trawling though endless digressions about the innards of the ABG machine, the following basic definitions are presented here as a summary to simplify rapid revision. They are either extracted from a classic article by J. McNamara and L.I.G. Worthley (2001) and annotated as "CICM definitions", or derived from official IUPAC publications. Links in this grey box will either take you to the peer-revieed article that supports the definition, or some of the locally available garbage pages full of gibberish.

Definition of acid:

  • CICM: A proton donor or H+ ion donor.
  • IUPAC: A molecular entity or chemical species capable of donating a hydron (proton) (see Brønsted acid) or capable of forming a covalent bond with an electron pair (see Lewis acid).

Definition of base

  • CICM: A proton acceptoror H+ ion acceptor.
  • IUPAC: A chemical species or molecular entity having an available pair of electrons capable of forming a covalent bond with a hydron (proton) (see Brønsted base) or with the vacant orbital of some other species (see Lewis base).

Models for the definitions of acid and base

  • Arrhenius: 
    • An acid is any substance which contributes hydrogen ions (H+) 

    • A base is any substance which contributes hydroxide ions (OH-) 

    • Neutrality is where [H+] = [OH-]

  • Brønsted-Lowry model
    • An acid is a substance from which a proton can be removed.
    • A base is a substance that can remove a proton from an acid.
      As in,
      HA + H2O → H3O+ + A-
    • Thus, the acid HA actually contains a "conjugate base", i.e. the A- which holds the proton in the absence of a solvent.
    • There is no definition for neutrality
  • Lewis model
    • A Lewis acid is a molecular entity (and the corresponding chemical species ) that is an electron-pair acceptor and therefore able to react with a Lewis base to form a Lewis adduct, by sharing the electron pair furnished by the Lewis base.
    • A Lewis base is a molecular entity (and the corresponding chemical species) able to provide a pair of electrons and thus capable of coordination to a Lewis acid, thereby producing a Lewis adduct.
  • These models compliment each other.
    • The Brønsted-Lowry model is well suited to the discussions of acid-base chemistry which involve aqueous solutions and protic acids
    • The Lewis model is more general and can be called upon to offer explanations of more exotic scenarios.

pH of neutrality

  • The pH of water at an autoiniosation equilibrium, described by

    H2O ⇌  H+ + OH- 
     
  • This is an endothermic reaction, which means it absorbs energy (i.e. the more energy is available, the more autoionisation will occur, and the lower the pH will be).
  • At 25 C° and 760 mmHg pressure, the pH of water is 7.0.
  • For every 1 degree increase, the neutral pH decreases by about 0.017
  • Thus, at 0 C°, the pH of water is 7.5

pH is the negative log(10) of H+ activity rather than concentration

  • This is a notional definition, which is not related to any sort of valid measurement
  • The log scale is for convenience: the concentration of H+ spans a huge range and is awkward to otherwise report
  • Normal arterial pH = 7.4 = H+ concentration of 40 mol/L
  • The negative logarithmic scale of pH is non-linear 
  • The relationship between pH and hydrogen concentration is inverse
  • One unit of pH decrease = tenfold increase in H+ concentration (or “activity”, more accurately)

Strength of an acid or base

  • A "strong acid" is one that dissociates fully (i.e. 100% of the acid is present in the form of ions)
  • A weak acid is incompletely disscoiated
  • The strentgth of an acid is described as the Ka, acid dissociation constant, where

    Ka = (A-) × (H+ ) / HA
     
  • A more useful version of this is pKa: the negative log(10) of Ka
  • A lower pKa means a stronger acid.
  • An acid of base will be 50% ionised when the pH of its solution is the same as its pKa.

References

For the history of acids and bases, apart from the lucid and comprehensive chapter from Kerry Brandis, one can turn to acid-base.com by Alan W. Grogono; the linked chapter draws heavily on the famous (in certain circles) book by Astrup and Severinghaus: The history of blood gases, acids, and bases ( Munksgaard, 1986). This opus is not available for free online, which is very sad (I'm looking at you, Google books).

McNamara, J., and L. I. G. Worthley. "Acid-base balance: part I. Physiology." Critical Care and Resuscitation 3.3 (2001): 181-187.

Those CICM definitons from this paper were in turn borrowed from the statements made during a 1960s symposium of the New York Academy of Sciences.

Buck, R. P., et al. "Measurement of pH. Definition, standards, and procedures (IUPAC Recommendations 2002). " Pure and applied chemistry 74.11 (2002): 2169-2200.