Buffering in acute respiratory acid-base disturbances

This chapter focuses on Section J1(iii) of the 2023 CICM Primary Syllabus, which expects the exam candidates to "describe the chemistry of buffer mechanisms and explain their roles in the body". Specifically, this is all about the ways in which a changing CO2 concentration might alter the pH of a solution, particularly that of your precious bodily fluids. The physiological consequences of acidaemia and

alkalaemia are discussed in dedicated chapters, as are the various effects of having an excessively high or precipitously low blood CO2 level (independent of pH changes). A chapter which summarises the bedside rules and equations used in the interpretation of blood gases is also available as a brief overview of the empirically derived formulae which describe acute and chronic compensation for acidosis and alkalosis.

Generally speaking, when asked "what happens in an acute respiratory acidosis", most people would spout something inane like "CO2 turns into acid", or equivalent. A more detailed explanation is expected from ICU staff. The best foundations for such an explanation can be found in Chapter 4.5 from "Acid-Base Physiology" by Brandis. The following "footnotes to Brandis" represent my attempt to explain these concepts to myself, slowly and patiently, as one might explain something to a toddler.

In summary:

  • CO2 carriage in the blood results in acidaemia because:
    • CO2 forms carbonic acid (H2CO3) in a reaction with water
    • Carbonic acid has a pKa of around 6.1-6.3, and is therefore fully dissociated at physiological pH, producing HCO3- and H+
    • The abundance of Hthis reaction produces has the effect of lowering pH
    • If not for 
  • The change in pH due to CO2 dissociation is ameliorated by several mechanisms:
    • Binding CO2 to remove it from the circulation:
      • Deoxyhaemoglobin binds CO2 (which forms carbamino compounds)
      • This contributes 10-20% to total CO2 carriage
      • This reaction still produces H+ which needs to be buffered
    • Buffering:
      • by intracellular elements:
        • Proteins (mainly haemoglobin)
        • Intracellular phosphate 
      • by extracellular elements:
        • plasma proteins
        • plasma phosphate
        • (minor contribution; low buffer capacity)
    • Hamburger shift
      • The rise in intracellular RBC HCO3- leads to the exchange of bicarbonate and chloride
      • Chloride is taken up by RBCSs, and bicarbonate is liberated.
      • Thus chloride concentration is lower in systemic venous blood than in systemic arterial blood
      • This mitigates some of the acidification of venous blood by increasing the strong ion difference

The behaviour of CO2 in the blood

Any discussion of acute respiratory acidosis should begin with an exploration of CO2 transport. Rather than to address this topic in detail here, one might summarise by saying that CO2 in the bloodstream is transported in three major forms: as dissolved gas, as carbamate (bound to haemoglobin and other proteins) and as bicarbonate. Bicarbonate is by far the most important form in terms of volume, and one gets their bicarbonate by either spontaneous or catalysed hydration of CO2, which becomes carbonic acid, and degenerates rapidly into HCO3- and H+.

The reaction can be summarised in this manner:

CO2 + H2O ⇌ H2CO⇌ HCO3- + H+

The CO2 and the bicarbonate here are familiar, but the intermediate carbonic acid step needs to be scrutinised further.

Carbonic acid: does it actually exist?

So, now you have performed the synthesis of CO2 and H2O into carbonic acid, H2CO3. This begs the question: how much of it is there? And if it were so important, then why don't we measure carbonic acid levels?

Well. Carbonic acid is a fairly fragile thing. Indeed, for a long time its existence was viewed assomething of a thought experiment like the hydrogen ion. Even such eminent bodies as PubChemrefer to it as a "hypothetical" acid. The reason for this sort of dismissive treatment is the extreme instability of carbonic acid under most physiological circumstances, and the consistent historical failures of people to identify and analyse a measurable quantity of it. When somebody did finally manage to make a small amount of it in 1993, its existence was confined to a thin frozen film in a methanol ice matrix, in a 77°K environment. Serious macroscopic amounts of carbonic acid, probably presenting in the form of amorphous lumps, might be found scattered liberally across the bleak tundra-like surface of Kuiper Belt objects (where near absolute zero temperatures protect it from degradation). The fact that it can only remain stable in such extreme environments adequately conveys the utter ridiculousness of looking for measurable quantities of H2CO3 in the body fluids of living human organisms.

However, there must be some amount of it present, because it is a necessary intermediate between the two sides of the CO2-HCO3- equation. So, how much H2CO3 is actually in the body at any given moment, even theoretically? No satisfactory consensus exists. Nunn's Respiratory Physiology (2005) quotes some unreferenced "published work" as a source for a figure of 1%. In other words, 1% of all transported CO2 is in the form of H2COat any given moment, either in the process of being converted to bicarbonate, or back again. This seems believable, given the ubiquity and industriousness of carbonic anhydrase.

With this knowledge, the effects of carbonic anhydrase on the raw substrates (CO2 and H2O) can be summarised in the following manner:

pragmatic diagram of carbonic anhydrase activity

This diagram, while acknowledging that H2CO3 is an intermediate product, appropriately trivialises its role in the process of converting CO2 and H2O into HCO3and H+.

However, H2CO3 does exist in the bloodstream, albeit in miniscule concentrations, and its contribution to physiology is non-trivial. Its importance lies in its being a weak acid. And at physiological pH, it is present in such minute concentrations precisely because most of it has dissociated. The result is a surplus of hydrogen ion activity, recognisable by ICU staff as a drop in pH.

Behaviour of carbonic acid as a Brønsted acid

Carbonic acid is a polyprotic acid in the old Brønsted acid sense; it is able to donate either one or two protons, with each dissociation having its own pKa value. In doing so, it generates a conjugate base - either HCO3- or CO32-. The former is clearly more likely: observe this Bjerrum plot for the dissociation of these three chemical species.

carbonic acid bjerrum plot

Weirdly, when one searches for such an image, one finds an exhausting array of plots specific to oceanic sea water and salt-water swimming pools, but very few specific to the human blood. Fortunately, a detailed examination of bicarbonate kinetics in the human bloodstream is available from Ole Siggaard-Andersen (1962). Apparently, the pKa of the first dissociation is about 6.1-6.3, and of the second somewhere around 9.3. Therefore at a normal physiological pH, the equilibrium equation is shifted heavily in favour of HCO3- and there is very little of the other species present.

Relationship of CO2 concentration and [H+]

So, how much H+ will be produced per change in pCO2? Well. One can use a stripped-down Henderson-Hasselbalch equation (simply, the Henderson equation) to assess the change in pH which is to be expected from a change in CO2.

equation of pH as a function of CO2 and HCO3 levels

Thus, the ratio of CO2 and HCO3 multiplied by a dissociation constant gives us an impression of the increase in hydrogen ion activity we can expect from the change in pCO2.

That "apparent" first dissociation constant is derived empirically, from experiments - there is no theoretical way to determine what that value should be (Nunn's reports that its value is 24, if the αpCO2 is represented in terms of mmHg). The [H+] output of this equation is in nmol/L. Thus, if one plugs in normal values, one ends up with a [H+] of around 40 nmol/L, which corresponds to a normal human blood pH of 7.40. 

The removal of CO2 from the circulation by haemoglobin

CO2 is also transported in the blood as carbamate compounds, dissociated conjugate bases of carbamino acids, many via haemoglobin.  Deoxyhaemoglobin has about 3.5 times the affinity for CO2 when compared to oxyhaemoglobin (this is the basis of the Haldane effect). The effect of removing CO2 from solution in this manner has the effect of increasing the pH, even though this process is not responsible for more than 10-20% of the total carriage of CO2

Unfortunately, each carbamino molecule that forms still produces a H+ ion, and this extra proton (plus whatever CO2-related H+ is left behind after carbamino formation) still needs to be buffered by something. 

Bicarbonate does not act as a buffer for CO2-related acidosis

Because that would be insane.

A buffer system cannot buffer itself. Consider: H2CO3, the product of H2O and CO2, dissociates into Hand HCO3-. What point would there be in HCO3binding H+ again? That would not be buffering; you would just get H2CO3 again, which would again dissociate and still generate H+, and the process would continue ad infinitum as an equilibrium reaction. Clearly, another system needs to soak up the extra H+ activity generated as a result of this process in order for true buffering to occur.

That system consists of intracellular phosphate and intracellular proteins, of which haemoglobin is the key player.

Buffering of respiratory acid-base disturbances by proteins and phosphate

buffering of CO2 acidosis by erythrocyte intracellular systems

As discussed far above (without the sillyness of diagrams) this concept can also be explained in terms of a nice adult-looking equilibrium equation:

CO2 + H2O ⇌ H2CO⇌ HCO3- + H+

Inside the red cells, intracellular carbonic anhydrase catalyses the conversion of CO2 and H2O into H2CO3, which exists for mere moments before decomposing spontaneously into HCO3- and H+.

If substrate is added to the left side of the equation, the equilibrium will shift right, favouring the production of H+ and bicarbonate. The H+ is then immediately absorbed by the vast supplies of intracellular phosphate, and the extensive collection of proteins (of which the chief is haemoglobin, because it is the most numerous - available at a concentration of 330g/L in the red cells).

Now, most people at this stage would complain that this reaction in the cells would grind to a halt once the intracellular HCO3- and Hconcentrations increase to a certain level. However, this equilibrium state is never reached.

The products of the reaction are constantly being removed:

The removal of bicarbonate from erythrocytes

Generally speaking, the bicarbonate content of intracellular fluid is remarkably low, and the content of extracellular fluid is remarkably high. Carbonic anhydrase is scarce in the bloodstream, and the spontaneous generation of H2COis slow and inefficient; thus the higher bicarbonate content of extracellular fluid is accounted for by the fact that HCO3- is actively pumped out of erythrocytes. This is called the Hamburger effect or the chloride shift, and it is mediated by the Band 3 transport protein.

The chloride shift or "the Hamburger effect"

Band 3 is unimaginatively named after the third strip of proteinaceous goop which develops when an electrophoresis of erythrocyte membranes is carried out. The Hamburger shift is also unimaginatively named after Hartog Jacob Hamburger, a man who was not only distinguished by a splendid handlebar moustache, but also - little it is known - is credited as the inventer of normal saline (!), which was briefly known as "Hamburger's Solution". This chapter is probably the wrong forum for any more saline-bashing; and in any case the chapter on the contents and properties of normal saline covers this sordid history in satisfying detail.

Back on topic. Band 3 is not merely an ion exchanger; it appears to be a huge complex molecule, with numerous other functions within the erythrocyte. For one, it acts as an anchor for the red cell cytoskeleton. Carbonic anhydrase seems to associate with it in a manner resembling the streamlining of a factory production line, ensuring that the new bicarbonate anions are shuttled out of the cell immediately. In short, Band 3 is critically important in the erythrocyte contribution to acid-base buffering. Its role as a facilitated diffusion mediator is pivotal to the passive movements of chloride and bicarbonate that are necessary for efficient gas exchange. For buffering, its role in the peripheral circulation consists of sequestering chloride into erythrocytes, and increasing the bicarbonate concentration in the peripheral blood. By these means, the Hamburger effect mitigates the change in pH which would otherwise occur in the peripheral circulation due to metabolic byproducts (mainly CO2). This effect is of sufficient exam interest that an entire chapter has been dedicated to it in the respiratory section. Here, it will suffice to report that some robust modelling has suggested the pH of venous blood  would end up being 7.22 instead of 7.35.

The net effect of CO2 increase on acid-base balance

At the end of such a long discussion of buffering mechanisms, the pragmatic intensivist- enraged by academic bullshit- would demand to know what happens to the acid-base balance. Rightly so. Whole-body buffering experiments (which have formed the basis of the Boston Bedside Rules) have revealed that in acute respiratory disorders, for every 10mmHg rise in CO2, the bicarbonate increases by 1mmol/L. Using this as a source of bicarbonate values, one can calculate the Henderson equation and estimate that this 10mmHg increase will drop the pH from 7.40 to about 7.33. This is  roughly what is observed in apnoeic anaesthetised patients: when their CO2 increased from 39 to 50 over the first minute, the average pH dropped from 7.42 to 7.34: 

pH and CO2 of apnoeic patients ofver 10 minutes - Stock et al, 1989

References

Martinu, Tereza, Dick Menzies, and Sandra Dial. "Re-evaluation of acid-base prediction rules in patients with chronic respiratory acidosis." Canadian respiratory journal: journal of the Canadian Thoracic Society 10.6 (2003): 311-315.

Jones, Norman L. "Respiratory acidosis sans acidemia." Canadian respiratory journal: journal of the Canadian Thoracic Society 10.6 (2003): 301-303.

Berend, Kenrick, Aiko PJ de Vries, and Rijk OB Gans. "Physiological approach to assessment of acid–base disturbances." New England Journal of Medicine371.15 (2014): 1434-1445.

Dorman, Philip J., W. James Sullivan, and Robert F. Pitts. "The renal response to acute respiratory acidosis." Journal of Clinical Investigation 33.1 (1954): 82.

Schwartz, William B., Adrien Falbriard, and Guy Lemieux. "The kinetics of bicarbonate reabsorption during acute respiratory acidosis." Journal of Clinical Investigation 38.6 (1959): 939.

Giebisch, Gerhard, et al. "The extrarenal response to acute acid-base disturbances of respiratory origin." Journal of Clinical Investigation 34.2 (1955): 231.

Brackett Jr, Newton C., Jordan J. Cohen, and William B. Schwartz. "Carbon dioxide titration curve of normal man: Effect of increasing degrees of acute hypercapnia on acid-base equilibrium." New England Journal of Medicine 272.1 (1965): 6-12.

Schwartz, William B., Newton C. Brackett Jr, and Jordan J. Cohen. "The response of extracellular hydrogen ion concentration to graded degrees of chronic hypercapnia: the physiologic limits of the defense of pH." Journal of Clinical Investigation 44.2 (1965): 291.

Goldstein, Marc B., F. John Gennari, and William B. Schwartz. "The influence of graded degrees of chronic hypercapnia on the acute carbon dioxide titration curve." Journal of Clinical Investigation 50.1 (1971): 208.

Alexander, James K., et al. "Analysis of the respiratory response to carbon dioxide inhalation in varying clinical states of hypercapnia, anoxia, and acid-base derangement." Journal of Clinical Investigation 34.4 (1955): 511.

Harned, Herbert S., and Raymond Davis Jr. "The ionization constant of carbonic acid in water and the solubility of carbon dioxide in water and aqueous salt solutions from 0 to 50." Journal of the American Chemical Society 65.10 (1943): 2030-2037.

Geers, Cornelia, and Gerolf Gros. "Carbon dioxide transport and carbonic anhydrase in blood and muscle." Physiological Reviews 80.2 (2000): 681-715.

Forster, R. E., and N. Itada. "Carbonic anhydrase activity in intact red cells as measured by means of 18O exchange between CO2 and water." Biophysics and Physiology of Carbon Dioxide. Springer Berlin Heidelberg, 1980. 177-183.

Loerting, Thomas, and Juergen Bernard. "Aqueous carbonic acid (H2CO3)."ChemPhysChem 11.11 (2010): 2305-2309.

Hage, Wolfgang, Andreas Hallbrucker, and Erwin Mayer. "Carbonic acid: synthesis by protonation of bicarbonate and FTIR spectroscopic characterization via a new cryogenic technique." Journal of the American Chemical Society 115.18 (1993): 8427-8431.

Moore, M. H., R. L. Hudson, and R. F. Ferrante. "Radiation products in processed ices relevant to Edgeworth-Kuiper-Belt objects." The First Decadal Review of the Edgeworth-Kuiper Belt. Springer Netherlands, 2004. 291-306.

Baer, E., and D. M. Reith. "Acetazolamide poisoning in a toddler." Journal of paediatrics and child health 37.4 (2001): 411-412.

Altay, S. "Acetazolamide overdose." Reactions 1510 (2014): 5-19.

Edgcomb, Stephen P., and Kenneth P. Murphy. "Variability in the pKa of histidine side‐chains correlates with burial within proteins." Proteins: Structure, Function, and Bioinformatics 49.1 (2002): 1-6.

Berenbrink, Michael. "Evolution of vertebrate haemoglobins: Histidine side chains, specific buffer value and Bohr effect." Respiratory physiology & neurobiology 154.1 (2006): 165-184.

Constable, Peter D. "Total weak acid concentration and effective dissociation constant of nonvolatile buffers in human plasma." Journal of Applied Physiology 91.3 (2001): 1364-1371.

Ellison, George, Jon V. Straumfjord, and J. P. Hummel. "Buffer capacities of human blood and plasma." Clinical chemistry 4.6 (1958): 452-461.

Rossi-Bernardi, L., and F. J. W. Roughton. "The specific influence of carbon dioxide and carbamate compounds on the buffer power and Bohr effects in human haemoglobin solutions." The Journal of physiology 189.1 (1967): 1-29.

Awad, Sherif, Simon P. Allison, and Dileep N. Lobo. "The history of 0.9% saline." Clinical nutrition 27.2 (2008): 179-188.

Westen, Edward A., and Henry D. Prange. "A reexamination of the mechanisms underlying the arteriovenous chloride shift." Physiological and Biochemical Zoology 76.5 (2003): 603-614.